We only rate brands which have at least some direct-to-consumer products, including those sold through comparison sites.

Fairer Finance Customer Experience Ratings are published twice a year – once in the spring, and once in the autumn.

Why we developed our ratings

The way that consumers buy financial products has changed over the past two decades. The growth of comparison sites has led to many more customers making their own choices when it comes to financial products, rather than taking advice.

Customers are now looking for shortcuts to make better decisions. Comparison sites have made it easy for customers to compare prices - but it's important that they can also compare products and brands on quality and service.

Our ratings are designed to help customers make more informed decisions, but they should not be taken as recommendations or advice. Every customer has different needs, and our ratings are simply designed as a short cut to help consumers make sense of the complex world of financial products.

Customer Experience Ratings: our criteria

There are four key metrics we use in our Customer Experience Ratings.

  • How happy are a firm’s customers?

  • How much do customers trust the firm?

  • How good is the provider at handling complaints?

  • How transparent is the provider?

However, in life insurance we don’t poll customer happiness and trust. Instead, we ask:

  • What percentage of life insurance claims are paid?

Each of these criteria is expressed as a percentage. We then work out the mean average of the four scores, which gives the overall percentage score for our Customer Experience Ratings.

How we gather data for these ratings

Happiness and trust

We use consumer polling to measure happiness and trust. Polling is conducted by independent polling company Opinium, using their nationally representative panel.

We receive tens of thousands of responses from these surveys every six months. These responses are analysed to provide a happiness and a trust score for each brand in our ratings. To learn more about our sample size please click here.

Complaints

To see how good financial firms are at handling complaints, we use data published by the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS). The fewer the complaints upheld in the customer’s favour at the FOS, the better the complaints performance of the company. We weight the most recent FOS data against data from previous periods to work out complaints scores for each six-month period.

Transparency

To see how transparent brands, we conduct our own analysis of purchase journeys and related terms and conditions or policy documents.

When analysing at a brand’s purchase journey, we check whether the key product information is provided – and how clearly explained and signposted this information is.

With product documents, we assess the clarity of the document’s design and language.

The purchase journey makes up 75% of the overall transparency score, with document analysis making up the other 25%.

Claims paid (life insurance only)

Providers publish ‘claims paid’ as a percentage every year.

We weight the most recent data against data from previous years. And then use further calculations to create our ‘claims paid’ percentage and the overall score in our Customer Experience Ratings.

If you want to take a more in-depth look at exactly how these scores are calculated, take a look at the PDF at the bottom of this page.

Ratings calculation

Once these key indicators have been analysed, and a Customer Experience Rating awarded, we apply further calculations to award Fairer Finance Ribbons.

We calculate the normal distribution of scores providers receive in each product area. This calculates where providers’ scores sit in relation to the product area average in terms of standard deviation.

Companies that receive a normal distribution score of 0.8 or above receive a Fairer Finance Gold Ribbon.

Those that receive a score between 0.7 and 0.8 receive a Fairer Finance Silver Ribbon. And those that receive a score between 0.6 and 0.7 receive a Fairer Finance Bronze Ribbon.

All other scores are not awarded a Fairer Finance Ribbon.

What our Customer Experience Ratings mean

Gold Ribbon

Brands that receive a Fairer Finance Gold Ribbon have performed better for customer experience than 80% of the market. They tend to excel at handling complaints, and at explaining the key features of the product in their documents and product journeys. They also tend to have the happiest and most trusting customers.

Silver Ribbon

Brands that are awarded a Fairer Finance Silver Ribbon have performed better than 70% of the market. They tend to have a strong record of handling complaints, and do a great job of explaining the key features of the product. They also tend to have happy and trusting customers.

Bronze Ribbon

Brands that are awarded a Fairer Finance Bronze Ribbon have performed better than 60% of the market. They tend to have a good record of handling complaints, and do a good job of explaining the key features of the product. They also tend to have fairly happy and trusting customers.

If you’d like to discuss using product endorsements on your marketing material - or find out more about out methodology, please email corporate@fairerfinance.com.

Want the full information on how our Customer Experience Ratings are calculated?

pdf

Customer Experience Ratings Full Methodology

Download

Thanks for providing your details.

You can now download the file you requested below:

Complete your download

Complete some details to download this free resource

In order to get access to this download we'd like to take some of your details so we can offer you support in this area.

How our Customer Experience and Product Ratings differ

pdf

Ratings Comparison Table

Download

Thanks for providing your details.

You can now download the file you requested below:

Complete your download

Complete some details to download this free resource

In order to get access to this download we'd like to take some of your details so we can offer you support in this area.