Our ratings are designed to help customers make more informed decisions, but they should not be taken as recommendations or advice. Every customer has different needs, and our ratings are simply designed as a short cut to help consumers make sense of the complex world of financial products.

Our product ratings are designed to help you choose a quality policy. We rate policies on the key features that are most important for the majority of customers.

Brand
Product name
Star rating
Courtesy car for duration of repair
Uninsured driver promise
Cover limit for lost keys
AA Car Insurance (Platinum) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,500.00
Age UK Trading Car Insurance (with guaranteed hire car) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes Unlimited
Asda Money Silver Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Autosan Car Insurance (with Enhanced courtesy car and increased personal accident) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,500.00
AXA Car Plus Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £2,500.00
Bank of Scotland Gold Car Insurance (with Courtesy Car Upgrade) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £2,500.00
BMW Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Churchill Plus Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Co-operative Insurance Motor Insurance (with guranteed hire car) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes Unlimited
Darwin Car Insurance (with guaranteed Hire Car Plus) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Direct Line Comprehensive Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Direct Line Comprehensive Plus Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Jaguar Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Land Rover Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Lloyds Bank Gold Car Insurance (with Courtesy Car Upgrade) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £2,500.00
Mercedes-Benz Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
MINI Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Moja Car Insurance (with courtesy car upgrade, personal belongings cover, child seat cover and Driving abroad cover) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £2,500.00
Policy Expert Gold (with key cover, replacement vehicle and Breakdown) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,500.00
Prima Car Insurance (with upgraded courtesy car) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,500.00
Privilege Car Insurance Comprehensive Plus Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Saga Plus Motor Insurance (with guaranteed hire car) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £750.00
Volvo Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
1st Central Extra Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,500.00
1st Central Extra + Breakdown Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,500.00
1st Central Extra + Legal Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,500.00
1st Central Extra + Premier Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,500.00
AA Car Insurance (Gold) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
AA Car Insurance (Silver) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £750.00
Admiral Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Admiral Gold Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Admiral Platinum Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Adrian Flux Car Insurance (AXA) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Adrian Flux Motor Insurance (Ageas Private Car) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £750.00
Adrian Flux Motor Insurance (Aviva Private Car) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Adrian Flux Motor Insurance (Covea Private Car) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Adrian Flux Motor Insurance (Markerstudy Private Car) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Age UK Trading Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 No Yes Unlimited
Ageas Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Ageas Car Insurance (with replacement vehicle) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Allianz Gold Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Allianz Silver Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Audi Plus Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Autosan Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,500.00
Aviva Gold Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Aviva Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Aviva Platinum Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Aviva Signature Motor Insurance with motor legal & enhanced courtesy car Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Bank of Scotland Gold Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £2,500.00
BEAM Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Brand
Product name
Star rating
Courtesy car for duration of repair
Uninsured driver promise
Cover limit for lost keys
RH Specialist Vehicle Insurance Stars awarded: 5
Adrian Flux Ageas Optima Classic Car Stars awarded: 4
Adrian Flux ERS Classic Car Stars awarded: 4
Classicline Insurance Classic Car Plus (Ageas) Stars awarded: 4
Classicline Insurance Specialist Vehicle (ERS) Stars awarded: 4
Classicline Insurance Specialist Vehicle (First Underwriting) Stars awarded: 4
Classicline Insurance Specialist Vehicle (Highway) Stars awarded: 4
Classicline Insurance Specialist Vehicle (KGM) Stars awarded: 4
Hagerty Classic Car Insurance (Aviva) Stars awarded: 4
Porsche Classic Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4
Classicline Insurance Classic Car (Ageas) Stars awarded: 3
Adrian Flux Cherished Car (Midas) Stars awarded: 2
Adrian Flux KGM Motor Specialist Vehicle Stars awarded: 2
Lancaster Insurance Classic Car Insurance Stars awarded: 2

Sorry, there are no ratings to show here just yet.

Brand
Product name
Star rating
Cover limit for lost keys
Courtesy car for duration of repair
Uninsured driver promise
Cover limit for Legal Liability Cover for property damage
Churchill DriveSure Plug-in Stars awarded: 5 £1,000.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Direct Line Drive plus Stars awarded: 5 £1,000.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Privilege Drive Xpert Stars awarded: 5 £1,000.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
1st Central Connect Stars awarded: 4 £1,500.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Admiral LittleBox Stars awarded: 4 £500.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Admiral LittleBox Plug & Drive Stars awarded: 4 £500.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Go Skippy Connect Stars awarded: 4 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Hastings Direct YouDrive Stars awarded: 4 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Hastings Direct YouDrive Premier Stars awarded: 4 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Marshmallow Move Orignal Stars awarded: 4 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Marshmallow Move Plus Stars awarded: 4 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Quotemehappy Connect Plus Stars awarded: 4 £300.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Quotemehappy Connect Premier Stars awarded: 4 £300.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
RAC Blackbox Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 £500.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Ticker New Driver Insurance Stars awarded: 4 £500.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Wise Driving Telematics Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 £750.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
WithStella Telematics Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 £1,000.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Zego Core Stars awarded: 4 £1,000.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Zego Max Stars awarded: 4 £1,000.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Acorn Insurance Protect Stars awarded: 3 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Carrot Insurance Telematics Stars awarded: 3 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Marmalade Blackbox Car Insurance Stars awarded: 3 £1,000.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
My Policy Car Insurance (Haven) Stars awarded: 3 £0.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Quotemehappy Connect Essentials Stars awarded: 2 £100.00 Yes Yes £20,000,000.00
Zego Essential Stars awarded: 2 £1,000.00 No Yes £20,000,000.00
Marshmallow Move Stars awarded: 1 £0.00 No No £20,000,000.00
Brand
Product name
Star rating
Courtesy car for duration of repair
Uninsured driver promise
Cover limit for lost keys
AA Car Insurance (Platinum) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,500.00
Allianz Gold Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes Unlimited
Autosan Car Insurance (with Enhanced courtesy car and increased personal accident) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,500.00
AXA Car Plus Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £2,500.00
BMW Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Churchill Plus Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Darwin Car Insurance (with guaranteed Hire Car Plus) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Direct Line Comprehensive Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Direct Line Comprehensive Plus Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Jaguar Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
John Lewis Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Land Rover Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Mercedes-Benz Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
MINI Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Moja Car Insurance (with courtesy car upgrade, personal belongings cover, child seat cover and Driving abroad cover) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £2,500.00
Porsche Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes Unlimited
Privilege Car Insurance Comprehensive Plus Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Saga Plus Motor Insurance (with guaranteed hire car) Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £750.00
Volvo Car Insurance Stars awarded: 5 Yes Yes £1,000.00
AA Car Insurance (Gold) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
AA Car Insurance (Silver) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £750.00
Admiral Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Admiral Gold Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Admiral Platinum Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Age UK Trading Car Insurance (with guaranteed hire car) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Ageas Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Ageas Car Insurance (with replacement vehicle) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Allianz Silver Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Audi Plus Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Autosan Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,500.00
Aviva Gold Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Aviva Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Aviva Platinum Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Aviva Signature Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 No Yes Unlimited
Aviva Signature Motor Insurance with motor legal & enhanced courtesy car Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Bank of Scotland Gold Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £2,500.00
Bank of Scotland Gold Car Insurance (with Courtesy Car Upgrade) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £2,500.00
BEAM Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Boom Car Insurance Premium Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,500.00
Churchill Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Churchill Car Insurance (Comparison site) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Co-operative Insurance Motor Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Co-operative Insurance Motor Insurance (with guranteed hire car) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes Unlimited
Darwin Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Darwin Gold Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Darwin Platinum Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Dial Direct Car Insurance (with guaranteed replacement car and keycare) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £1,000.00
Diamond Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Diamond Car Insurance (hire vehicle) Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00
Elephant Car Insurance Stars awarded: 4 Yes Yes £500.00