Car insurance

Start your search for a good value car insurer by looking at Fairer Finance's latest ratings.

Our ratings are designed to help customers make more informed decisions, but they should not be taken as recommendations or advice. Every customer has different needs, and our ratings are simply designed as a short cut to help consumers make sense of the complex world of financial products.

Brand Customer
happiness
Customer
trust
Complaints
performance
Transparency
rating
Customer Experience rating

What does this mean?

What does this mean?

What does this mean?

What does this mean?

Gold

CSIS

CSIS
73.53% 77.21% 97.5% 67.07% 79%
Gold

NFU Mutual

NFU Mutual
82.48% 78.86% 79.72% 65.45% 77%
Gold

John Lewis

John Lewis
83.98% 83.98% 68.14% 59.21% 74%
Gold

BMW

BMW
85.23% 77.27% 59.09% 58.36% 71%
Gold

Marks & Spencer

Marks & Spencer
66.42% 60.24% 80.26% 63.03% 67%
Gold

1st Central

1st Central
67.49% 59.42% 76.49% 60.42% 66%
Silver

Direct Line

Direct Line
64.28% 54.36% 74.87% 64.37% 65%
Silver

Bell

Bell
70.83% 56.77% 74.73% 55.01% 64%
Silver

Age Co

Age Co
67.27% 65% 65.26% 56.93% 64%
Bronze

Halifax

Halifax
60.69% 50.87% 77.41% 64.5% 63%
Bronze

LV=

LV=
66.7% 54.45% 75.51% 53.92% 63%

Toyota

73.89% 66.67% 73.37% 35.89% 63%

A Choice

60.68% 62.14% 74.6% 52.21% 62%

Quotemehappy

62.49% 46.97% 72.32% 53.6% 62%

Tesco Bank

58.57% 52.17% 68.99% 68.3% 62%

Churchill

56.55% 49.67% 78.24% 63.5% 62%

Lloyds Bank

62.92% 56.76% 76.63% 50.85% 62%

Sainsbury's

63.21% 57.31% 81.04% 44.42% 62%

Dial Direct

63.49% 43.25% 77.76% 61.56% 62%

Hastings Direct

58.04% 46.9% 74.32% 66.56% 62%

Co-operative Insurance

61.33% 56.22% 75.99% 51.73% 61%

RIAS

64.35% 51.72% 71.47% 47.38% 61%

Privilege

53.94% 40.71% 76.09% 44.68% 61%

Policy Expert

49.39% 43.29% 76.38% 54.58% 61%

Admiral

60.62% 50.25% 74.73% 56.87% 61%

Elephant

56.42% 54.81% 75.36% 55.01% 60%

Aviva

62.56% 55.68% 73.29% 47.08% 60%

Santander

57.65% 58.24% 84.45% 50.42% 60%

Diamond

61.67% 47.7% 74.73% 55.54% 60%

AXA

58.43% 53.86% 63.5% 66.94% 60%

Saga

64.13% 57.01% 71.95% 52.23% 59%

Provident

59.44% 48.95% 73.91% 58.56% 59%

Abbey Autoline

64.94% 51.44% 68.45% 50.8% 59%

AA

58.2% 56.54% 73.45% 46.9% 59%

esure

56.47% 45.43% 78.71% 50.65% 58%

One Call Insurance

49.86% 37.99% 85.28% 57.84% 58%

RAC

56.89% 57.62% 67.14% 61.97% 58%

Swinton

52.41% 45.17% 73.08% 59.84% 58%

More Than

57.07% 47.6% 60.07% 64.96% 57%

Budget

54.87% 53.33% 77.38% 49.23% 57%

Brightside

55.56% 45.37% 76.85% 50.41% 57%

4 Young Drivers

68.4% 59.82% 66.41% 37.81% 57%

Endsleigh

58.65% 46.99% 72.04% 48.08% 57%

Autonet

54.92% 49.18% 75.9% 50.72% 56%

GoSkippy

53.16% 46.84% 75.28% 43.84% 55%

Sheilas' Wheels

59.32% 47.71% 73.12% 47.31% 55%

Swiftcover

51.81% 35.14% 64% 57.14% 54%

Post Office Money

58.76% 55.58% 74.62% 51.91% 53%

Hughes Insurance

58.51% 46.28% 63.64% 42.49% 53%

Ageas

52.93% 43.51% 65.26% 47.45% 52%

Acorn Insurance

42.79% 46.85% 61.52% 51.74% 51%

More customer experience ratings