Car insurance

Start your search for a good value car insurer by looking at Fairer Finance's latest ratings.

Our ratings are designed to help customers make more informed decisions, but they should not be taken as recommendations or advice. Every customer has different needs, and our ratings are simply designed as a short cut to help consumers make sense of the complex world of financial products.

Brand Customer
happiness
Customer
trust
Complaints
performance
Transparency
rating
Customer Experience rating

What does this mean?

What does this mean?

What does this mean?

What does this mean?

Gold

CSIS

CSIS
78.26% 73.91% 90% 74.95% 79%
Gold

Bank of Scotland

Bank of Scotland
82.7% 81.62% 77.35% 70.72% 78%
Gold

NFU Mutual

NFU Mutual
81.73% 77.91% 81.93% 68.8% 78%
Gold

Abbey Autoline

Abbey Autoline
78.34% 77.01% 74% 74.85% 76%
Gold

Santander

Santander
75.68% 72.97% 77.35% 71.06% 74%
Gold

John Lewis

John Lewis
69.9% 86.73% 78.12% 57.84% 73%
Gold

Age Co

Age Co
74.05% 71.76% 68.57% 71.39% 71%
Gold

4 Young Drivers

4 Young Drivers
83.6% 78.8% 69% 53.05% 71%
Gold

Marks & Spencer

Marks & Spencer
66.97% 62.73% 77.35% 73.15% 70%
Gold

Geoffrey Insurance

Geoffrey Insurance
66.36% 69.09% 71.83% 72.56% 70%
Silver

Toyota

Toyota
76.15% 72.31% 78% 49.26% 69%
Silver

A Choice

A Choice
68.91% 67.65% 83.33% 54.24% 69%
Silver

Adrian Flux

Adrian Flux
72.32% 68.3% 76% 56.7% 68%
Silver

Lloyds Bank

Lloyds Bank
65.28% 58.07% 77.35% 72.52% 68%
Bronze

BMW

BMW
78.74% 74.41% 54.52% 61.87% 67%
Bronze

LV=

LV=
66.1% 56.57% 77.38% 68.35% 67%
Bronze

Brightside

Brightside
64.62% 61.54% 73.46% 68.51% 67%
Bronze

Bell

Bell
76.25% 56.25% 73.18% 62.37% 67%
Bronze

Direct Line

Direct Line
65.71% 56.32% 75.09% 68.43% 66%
Bronze

Diamond

Diamond
64.97% 58.84% 73.18% 66.32% 66%

Tesco Bank

62.31% 55.79% 80.5% 63.18% 65%

AA

62.49% 59.95% 70.61% 68.54% 65%

Budget

58.19% 55.17% 77.35% 68.76% 65%

Co-operative Insurance

65.75% 59.09% 78% 54.96% 64%

Halifax

55.02% 52.07% 77.35% 71.85% 64%

RAC

55.13% 54.87% 77.35% 68.58% 64%

Post Office Money

50.93% 58.41% 77.35% 69.09% 64%

Admiral

62.17% 52.96% 73.18% 66.57% 64%

Churchill

58.5% 51.09% 75.09% 66.19% 63%

Aviva

62.97% 57.18% 73.07% 56.04% 62%

Quotemehappy

60.42% 45.75% 73.23% 69.3% 62%

Sheilas' Wheels

61.78% 48.62% 85.61% 52.07% 62%

General Accident

62.66% 47.72% 73.04% 62.96% 62%

Saga

65.42% 57.53% 72.28% 51.09% 62%

Swinton

55.72% 47.61% 78.77% 62.59% 61%

Sainsbury's

60.76% 54.64% 68.24% 60.23% 61%

Hastings Direct

58.05% 45.88% 75.33% 63.64% 61%

esure

58.68% 47.85% 80.68% 55.32% 61%

AXA

62.72% 54.49% 59.38% 65.84% 61%

Provident

59.82% 49.11% 78.52% 54.22% 60%

1st Central

65.75% 56.79% 60.62% 57.97% 60%

Acorn Insurance

65.63% 58.59% 59.63% 55.57% 60%

Elephant

54.12% 46.39% 73.18% 65.38% 60%

Privilege

57.31% 45.58% 75.09% 57.1% 59%

Dial Direct

49.52% 38.57% 77.35% 69.49% 59%

One Call Insurance

52.06% 43.54% 80.57% 58.09% 59%

RIAS

58.04% 50.64% 69.03% 56.35% 59%

More Than

54.29% 47.55% 67.52% 64.18% 58%

Ageas

57.54% 48.28% 68.57% 54.97% 57%

Hughes Insurance

62.5% 43.75% 59% 58.22% 56%

Autonet

48.18% 37.27% 79.98% 57.43% 56%

Swiftcover

50.98% 36.27% 59.38% 73.54% 55%

GoSkippy

55% 43.33% 65.57% 52.42% 54%

More customer experience ratings