Harry Ashton

By Harry Ashton

Trust hits record high

Trust in private medical insurance (PMI) has improved over the last 6 months after it had started to plateau in the previous year according to the latest Fairer Finance customer experience ratings.

In Fairer Finance’s latest customer experience polling of over 10,000 PMI customers trust scores have risen by 0.86p.p since Spring 2026, now standing at 59.3%. This is the highest score recorded since Fairer Finance began tracking trust in Autumn 2023, surpassing the previous high of 58.57% set in Autumn 2024.


Claims satisfaction continues its upward trend

Claims satisfaction has continued its upward trajectory. Claims satisfaction has risen another 1.42p.p in the last 6 months, climbing to 67.5% - an increase of almost 12p.p. in the last 3 and a half years. Good claims experience continues to be one of the strongest drivers of trust. Customers who have made a claim in the last 3 years trust their provider far more than those who haven't (66.58% vs 54.87%).


The mid-life trust dip is widening

In every single wave since polling began customers aged 46-64 have had the lowest trust of any age group.

The gap between the most trusting age group (18-30) and the least trusting (46-64) has widened from 3.6p.p in Autumn 2023 to 8.7p.p today. Trust among younger customers has climbed steadily, while the 46-64 age group has barely moved in three years. This is typically the life stage where customers first encounter more complex health needs and higher-value claims and where any gap between expectation and experience is felt most acutely.

Claims satisfaction improving for younger customers

However, younger customers have seen a big increase in trust scores this wave. For 18-30 year olds trust scores have risen over 20% in the last 3 years including 6% in the last 6 months. And for 31-45 year olds it has jumped 7.46% in the last 6 months and almost 15% in the last 3 years.


One reason for improving claims satisfaction could possibly be improvements made in digital customer experience. There has been a rise in the customer satisfaction scores for both digital customer service and the app/website/online customer portal. Perhaps these are linked to a more streamlined claims process from providers resulting in the rise in trust and claims satisfaction scores.

Vulnerability gap widens again

The gap in trust between vulnerable and non-vulnerable customers had narrowed in Autumn 2025 to 2.81p.p, but has now widened back out to 5.37p.p (55.99% vs 61.36%) - its widest point on record suggesting there is more providers can do to improve trust with vulnerable customers. 


Trust and claims by brand:

WPA has returned to their spot as the most trusted provider despite a small drop in their score which now stands at 63.4%. Two of the largest providers in the market AXA Health and Aviva both saw improvement in this wave with rises of 2.71p.p and 1.4p.p respectively. 

Claims follows a similar trend with WPA also leading the way with a claims satisfaction score of 71.55%